Grid-Iron american football game language selector
Language
ČeštinaDanskDeutsch
EnglishEspañolEspañol (Latinoamérica)
FrançaisItalianoMagyar
NederlandsPolskiPortuguês (Brasil)
RomânăSlovenčinaSlovenščina
SrpskiSuomiБългарски
РусскийУкраїнська 
Register
Login
Player Evaluations and Advice.- moved to Rookie Forum
Forum index >> Grid-Iron discussions >> Player Evaluations and Advice.- moved to Rookie Forum Goto page : 1, 2, 3 ... 10, 11, 12
 
buckeye1022
Posts: 8799
Posted on 2008-12-09 5:37:59
Mercutioh wrote:

i speak for myself when I say Doh!



And I simply need to start reading things before posting.
Gurudefence
Posts: 0
Posted on 2008-12-13 1:05:06
iMan24 wrote:

first here are 2 players i own
Player A
Positioning 7 , Tackling 6 , Punting 5
Vision 6 , Blocking 4 , Speed 13
Intelligence 9 , Passing 2 , Strength 13
Footwork 6 , Catching 4 , Agility 4
Carrying 7 , Kicking 5 , Stamina 7

Player B
Positioning 1 , Tackling 2 , Punting 3
Vision 4 , Blocking 1 , Speed 14
Intelligence 14 , Passing 2 , Strength 13
Footwork 3 , Catching 3 , Agility 5
Carrying 5 , Kicking 3 , Stamina 2

What i plan to do is play player A at FB and then player B at MLB
i have most of my best players on defense (the defense will be the center of my team) and player B has more talent. am i making the right choice?
Gurudefence
Posts: 0
Posted on 2008-12-13 1:06:25
Personally, NO! It should be the other way around in my opinion.

Player A is a much better Linebacker than Player B.

Player B is not great, but may be okay at Full Back. Admittedly he has terrible blocking skills, but we have no idea how much Blocking is needed by a Full Back. Sure, in real life, lots....But here is always different.

But then Player A would be great in numerous positions. Only thing going for Player B at Linebacker is his Intelligence.
Mercutioh
Posts: 7396
Posted on 2008-12-13 1:14:13
and agility for lbs as well, but yes I agree whole heartedly with guru. FB is not a position that wins you games singlehandedly, LB definitely is.
iMan24
Posts: 2
Posted on 2008-12-13 1:17:08
Gurudefence wrote:

Personally, NO! It should be the other way around in my opinion.

Player A is a much better Linebacker than Player B.

Player B is not great, but may be okay at Full Back. Admittedly he has terrible blocking skills, but we have no idea how much Blocking is needed by a Full Back. Sure, in real life, lots....But here is always different.

But then Player A would be great in numerous positions. Only thing going for Player B at Linebacker is his Intelligence.



thanks for the reply. I thought player b would be better since he has more talent and intelligence.

how much should i value talent?
Gurudefence
Posts: 0
Posted on 2008-12-13 1:19:58
iMan24 wrote:


how much should i value talent?



Talent, at this early stage in the game, is absolutely useless.

It enables players to have higher skill sets in regards to Offence, Defence, Tactical and Kicking. Noone has even breached the 10/11 skill barriers yet...!

Ofcourse, if you want him to become a super-star, he can be. But not until another 3/4 seasons, which is when his Talent will be worth something.
Mercutioh
Posts: 7396
Posted on 2008-12-13 1:32:24
it all depends on how long term you want to plan. If you plan on making this a 2-3 season run. Then I agree with Guru. Forget Talent let it ride on high teamwork and consistency. If you want to play the game for the long run keeping an eye on talent is a big priority. the higher a players talent to longer he can stay on your team as a usable prospect. Players with High talent will go for larger money in the long run on the market, on the flip side of this. I will almost guarantee that you can't keep a teamful of 5 star talents together when they are fully trained. the wages will react accordingly. Keep that in mind and you can make your own call on how important talent is for a given position.
Serrie
Posts: 3125
Posted on 2008-12-13 9:52:10
I don't buy players with less than 4 stars talent.
I'm planning for the future
skinkeskyter
Posts: 0
Posted on 2008-12-13 12:04:12
I was wondering were i should put this player.
Positioning 5 Tackling 3 Punting 7
Vision 5 Blocking 7 Speed 13
Intelligence 18 Passing 6 Strength 10
Footwork 5 Catching 7 Agility 3
Carrying 5 Kicking 5 Stamina 3
Teamwork 16 Consistency 15

He is also 16 so he is kinda my star player. First i put him as a HB but recently i have put him as a FB and this player as a HB.

SKILLS
Positioning 2 Tackling 2 Punting 4
Vision 1 Blocking 3 Speed 12
Intelligence 17 Passing 3 Strength 14
Footwork 4 Catching 2 Agility 6
Carrying 5 Kicking 3 Stamina 5
Teamwork 3 Consistency 18

Any suggestions to were you think they are best suited?

Krs71
Posts: 1380
Posted on 2008-12-13 12:29:09
Sell the first one to me, and put the second one on the HB(lock)

First one can play everywhere on offense, if he has TE in his positions I suggest TE
 
Forum index >> Grid-Iron discussions >> Player Evaluations and Advice.- moved to Rookie Forum Goto page : 1, 2, 3 ... 10, 11, 12
Last posts
2024-05-18 10:16
Ligathread
Author:liberalmente
2024-05-18 9:25
regional cup
Author:Loebuck
2024-05-18 7:45
Nationalmannschaft
Author:juergenmainz
2024-05-18 7:37
DACH Cup
Author:Frank Raid
2024-05-17 9:25
Championnat de France saison 19 discussion et envoi de defis
Author:Tsubasa0zora
2024-05-16 23:16
Ligathread
Author:Klomgo
2024-05-16 22:47
Ligathread
Author:Baphomet
2024-05-16 16:21
DACH Cup
Author:kostuek